Podcast: Play in new window | Download
What are the pros and cons of the different ACL graft options, like a hamstring graft, patellar tendon graft or allograft, for ACL surgery? I address this concept in my latest Ask Dr. Geier column.
Hello Dr. Geier, I am 48 years old young lady who plays tennis every day, and occasionally I also play basketball and soccer. Tennis is my life, and I also coach my kids. I was playing tennis and fell and torn my ACL. I have done some research and have decided to use the hamstring graft. My problem is that I cannot find a sport orthopaedic surgeon who specializes in the hamstring graft. Every doctor I check specializes in either the patella graft or a cadaver graft.
Thank you for the question. I have written about graft options in ACL surgery previously, and I encourage all interested readers to check out my opinions. I perform about two or three of these surgeries per week, and while I utilize hamstring and cadaver grafts sometimes, I as well use the patellar tendon grafts most commonly. I still think it is the gold standard with pro athletes, so it makes sense to me to use it in everyone. Having said that, hamstring grafts are used for most young kids, while cadaver grafts are used for older athletes, and both can be used for other athletes.
The main point I want to make with ACL graft options deals with selection of surgeons. First of all, I want to applaud the writer of this question for performing research about her injury and surgery. It seems to me that many patients don’t think about their injuries enough and don’t ask enough questions. That can lead to bad situations where patients are surprised that recovery takes longer than they expected or they hurt more than they expected. In general, I want to encourage all of you readers out there to ask questions and know everything you can about your surgery and rehabilitation. After all, it is your body, and you need it to be as healthy as possible for years to come.
Ask your surgeon about graft options for ACL surgery
Second, I would point out that surgeons are all going to have biases. Obviously I do, as I pointed out in the earlier paragraphs. I would have a patellar tendon graft if I tore my ACL, and I say that based on experience and scientific literature. When an athlete goes to see a surgeon, she should ask about options and get information that helps her make a choice. In this case, the reader should ask the surgeon about graft options and find out about the risks and benefits of them (like I discuss in the post about graft options). With that information, the patient can make a decision that is best for her. If she feels that the surgeon is forcing her to pick what he wants to do and she isn’t comfortable with that option, she should find another surgeon.
ACL graft options and outcomes
Lastly, with ACL surgeries (and many other sports medicine and arthroscopic surgeries), the outcome depends more on the quality of the surgery and the technical procedure than on the ACL graft options. In this case, surgeons that perform 100 or more ACL reconstructions per year are usually familiar with all grafts and can easily use any of them. In my experience, while we might choose to use one more frequently, those of us who do them frequently are good at all of them. The surgeons who don’t do them very often are usually only good at one technique. And there are far more surgeons who perform these surgeries 20 or fewer times a year than ones who perform 100 or more. The technical skill of the surgeon and the quality of the physical therapy seem more important in overall outcome than does the graft selection, in my opinion.
Recommended Products and Resources
Click here to go to Dr. David Geier’s Amazon Influencer store!
Due to a large number of questions I have received over the years asking about products for health, injuries, performance, and other areas of sports, exercise, work and life, I have created an Amazon Influencer page. While this information and these products are not intended to treat any specific injury or illness you have, they are products I use personally, have used or have tried, or I have recommended to others. THE SITE MAY OFFER HEALTH, FITNESS, NUTRITIONAL AND OTHER SUCH INFORMATION, BUT SUCH INFORMATION IS DESIGNED FOR EDUCATIONAL AND INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. THE CONTENT DOES NOT AND IS NOT INTENDED TO CONVEY MEDICAL ADVICE AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE THE PRACTICE OF MEDICINE. YOU SHOULD NOT RELY ON THIS INFORMATION AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR, NOR DOES IT REPLACE, PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL ADVICE, DIAGNOSIS, OR TREATMENT. THE SITE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY ACTIONS OR INACTION ON A USER’S PART BASED ON THE INFORMATION THAT IS PRESENTED ON THE SITE. Please note that as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.