Oscar Pistorius: Source of controversy or inspiration?

Track finish lineNormally a sprinter beating an Olympic qualifying time would not generate much interest outside of die-hard track and field enthusiasts. But when Oscar Pistorius broke 45.30 seconds in the 400 meters recently, the sports world started to notice. If the sprinter considered South Africa’s sexiest celebrity breaks that mark again in the adidas Grand Prix next month and qualifies for the Olympics, casual sports fans everywhere will pay attention. Why? Oscar Pistorius has no legs.

The 25-year-old sprinter was born without fibulas, which are the long bones on the outside of the legs. His parents were forced to make a difficult choice to have a surgeon amputate both of his lower extremities below the knees when he was just 11 months old. They decided early amputation would allow him the best chance to learn to walk normally.

Pistorius not only learned to walk on prosthetic limbs within the first years of his life, but he became an elite athlete. Competing with carbon-fiber blades called Flex-Foot-Cheetahs, he is a four-time gold medalist at the Paralympic Games in the 100, 200, and 400-meter distances. In 2005 he began competing against able-bodied sprinters and challenging their times.

In 2007 the International Association of Athletics Federations asked Pistorius to undergo a series of tests. Dr. Peter Bruggemann at the Cologne Sports University reported that Pistorius’s prosthetic limbs gave him a “bouncing” locomotion that required a lower metabolic cost than able-bodied runners. Consequently the IAAF banned him from able-bodied competitions.

Pistorius underwent a second series of tests at Rice University and appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport. The arbitrators ruled that the data showed Pistorius used the same amounts of oxygen and “fatigued normally” over the course of the entire 400 meters. He was then allowed to compete against able-bodied sprinters despite his Cheetahs.

Unfortunately that ruling did not end the debate over whether Pistorius has a competitive advantage. The second team of scientists had dissenting opinions. One of those scientists, Peter Weyand, a professor of applied physiology and biomechanics at Southern Methodist University has publicly argued that Pistorius does, in fact, have an advantage.

Prosthetic Runner
Oscar Pistorius competes with carbon-fiber blades called Flex-Foot-Cheetahs on each lower extremity, similar to the prosthesis seem here.
Weyand points out that the team of scientists at Rice only had to refute the original finding of lower oxygen consumption by Dr. Bruggemann. He argues that they did not have to disprove what Weyand argues is Pistorius’s biggest advantage – namely the ability to reposition his limbs more quickly. The Cheetah blades weigh about 5.4 pounds, compared to the approximately 12.6 pounds that a similar-sized runner’s leg would weigh. He claims Pistorius’s “swing times” therefore are significantly faster than the sprinters with legs.

Weyand and fellow author Matthew Bundle showed that Pistorius could reposition his limbs in 0.28 seconds. The average limb-repositioning times of five former 100-meter world-record holders (Ben Johnson, Carl Lewis, Maurice Greene, Tim Montgomery, and Justin Gatlin) is 0.34 seconds. Shorter limb repositioning times theoretically decrease the time spent in the air and the force needed to push off and propel his body forward.

The lead researcher who defended Pistorius to the CAS and challenged the IAAF, Hugh Herr, argues that prostheses, like the ones he wears, without muscles, tendons, ligaments, and nerves, offer no advantage. He compares running on the Cheetahs, whose technology is 10-20 years old, to running on a mattress.

His supporters note that Pistorius has disadvantages compared to able-bodied sprinters, especially his inability to explode out of the blocks. Likewise, Pistorius contends that amputee sprinters on the same Cheetahs cannot approach his dominance in the 400 meters. He also points out that a few sprinters who later suffered injuries requiring amputation never again matched their able-bodied times.

There is likely not an option that will satisfy everyone. If we allow amputee sprinters wearing Cheetahs to compete, should the sport allow prostheses with newer technology as well? Since the limbs are lighter, should the weight be equalized to match those of normal limbs? The CAS might have opened a Pandora’s box of issues by allowing him to compete, right or wrong.

Pistorius and amputee sprinters like him have different running mechanics than able-bodied ones. With those differences come advantages and disadvantages. But even if they provided a competitive edge, would many athletes permanently sacrifice their healthy legs to race with carbon-fiber blades?

If Pistorius, nicknamed “Blade Runner,” beats 45.30 seconds for the third time June 9 in New York, he will become the first amputee track and field runner to qualify for the Summer Olympics. If he does earn the right to compete against able-bodied runners, it will be fascinating to see how the media and public regard him. Is Oscar Pistorius an inspiring role model, an athlete with an unfair competitive advantage, or both?

What are your thoughts? Should Pistorius be viewed as a role model to inspire both able-bodied and amputee athletes? Do you think he has a competitive advantage? Share your opinions below!

Note: A modified version of this post appears in my sports medicine column in the May 24, 2012 issue of The Post and Courier.

One Response to Oscar Pistorius: Source of controversy or inspiration?

Leave a reply

ABOUT ME
david-headshot I am an orthopaedic surgeon and sports medicine specialist in Charleston, South Carolina.

On this blog, on my podcast, and in articles for numerous publications and in media interviews, I aim to provide you leading commentary and education on injury treatment and prevention to keep you performing at your best! Learn more about me >>


MEDIA

I'm excited to help with information and interviews for print, radio, television, and online media. Media information >>

WRITING

Writing I write articles and columns for a number of publications and organizations. Writing information >>
Sports Medicine Simplified: A Glossary of Sports Injuries, Treatments, Prevention and Much More

glossary-cover
Learn more about the glossary >>
© 2014 Dr. David Geier Enterprises, LLC

Site Designed by Launch Yourself